Western New York's best place for new and gently used sporting goods and equipment. Our inventory is always changing so stop by to check for great deals. If we don't have it, we can get it.

Store Policies

  • New items have a 10 day return policy as long as they were not used.
  • Used items have a 10 day return policy for store credit only. No exceptions!

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What items are you currently purchasing?

    Buffalo Sports purchases equipment seasonally. We buy summer sports (soccer, baseball, lacrosse) during the spring and summer and winter sports (snow sports, hockey) during the fall and winter.
  • Can I call if I'm not sure?

    We always recommend calling us to give us a brief description of your used items. Remember, we only buy gently used, modern sporting equipment.
  • I have something unique. Do I have to wait for the right season?

    No way! If you have a major item or some high-end equipment (hockey skates, treadmills, goalie equipment, golf clubs), bring it in or call us. We buy certain items year round.
  • How much do you pay for used equipment?

    We typically offer 50% of our resale value in the form of store credit. Cash offers vary due to multiple factors - current inventory levels, demand for your items, and seasonal timing all apply. Please call, we always try to be as fair as possible. Keep in mind we do not give quotes over the phone. We must physically see your equipment in order to make a fair offer.
  • Can I get more money if I try to sell it on my own?

    Maybe. If you have the time, you might be able to get a better value after you take pictures, write up a description, post it on an auction site, answer seller questions, wait for payment, package it up, mail it off, and handle any complaints.